For years I have watched, read, and listened to a growing number of natural horsemanship trainers. As a natural horsemanship practitioner myself, I want to be pleased at its increasing popularity. But I was recently an observer at a natural horsemanship clinic in my area, and feel the need to speak out against something I see far too often.
I began my own study of natural horsemanship in the 1970s when I read the wonderful book Such is the Real Nature of Horses by Robert Vavra. It wasn’t about training, but rather a book of Mr. Vavra’s beautiful wild horse photography along with his insight into their nature. It has remained one of my favorite reads and was the beginning of my journey into the study of natural horsemanship. Thirty plus years later, I am still learning.
Natural horsemanship, in its essence, is developing an understanding of the horse in nature, and working with the horse’s nature, rather than against it, to develop a willing partnership.
So, when I see “professionals” training horses under the guise of natural horsemanship, teaching techniques involving pain-inducing leverage, I am both saddened and appalled. Not only is there often nothing natural in their techniques or approach, they do not respect or consider the horse as a partner. They may be able to achieve an obedient and compliant horse, but they are doing it through fear. Horses may submit to their request, but after what I see as brutality. These trainers demand respect, yet they have no respect for the horse.
There are two types of leaders: one that bullies and one that leads through example. If horses are put in a herd with two dominant horses, they will always choose to follow the “passive leader.” This should be no surprise — people don’t like being bullied either. So why would anyone think a horse would become a willing partner through the same techniques?
What distresses me in addition to the horses that suffer through this training is the vast number of people following like sheep behind some of these trainers. Yes, what they can accomplish may seem impressive, but have these people looked into their horses eyes? Do they not see the fear, the resignation, and the broken spirit of their horse? A student recently talked to me about a horse she had in training. She was worried that the trainer was terrorizing her horse. She expressed her concerns to the trainer but was promptly reprimanded and made to feel like she had no right to question what was being done — the trainer was the professional, after all! NO! IT IS YOUR HORSE AND YOUR RESPONSIBILITY TO PROTECT HIM/HER. IT IS YOUR RIGHT TO SAY “NO.” It is also your right to not allow a trainer to bully you!
Information on training techniques is so readily available to all of us. We can buy books, we can research the internet, there are videos, demonstrations, and seminars everywhere! Before following a trainer, I encourage everyone to take the time to do some research. What is his/her background of study? What have they accomplished? Watch them work with some horses and people. What is their rapport with them? You can easily see a horse is worried when approached by someone who has hurt them. Trust your instincts and continue your search if you have any apprehension.
Pain and fear are not the way to create a partnership with your horse. No matter what your experience level, you are ultimately responsible for how your horse is trained and treated. It is never okay to hit, tie-down, or in any other way cause pain to a horse. Horse lovers, people who strive to be good horsemen, know this instinctively. Don’t let anyone, “professional” though they may claim to be, misguide you.